If your child is ready to begin music lessons, congratulations, that’s a big step! But now you’re faced with another question that stumps a lot of parents: Should we start with the violin or the guitar?
Both are fantastic choices with long-term benefits, but each has its own learning curve, physical considerations, and “early win” potential. The key is finding the right fit for your child, not just for now, but for a rewarding musical journey ahead.
Book a free consultation today
Guitar: Frets, Familiarity, and Faster Results
Guitar is a popular first instrument, and for good reason. It’s accessible, rewarding, and fits a wide range of musical tastes.
Why some kids gravitate towards guitar:
- Fretted fingerboard: Frets make it easier for beginners to land on the right notes without needing perfect finger placement.
- Faster progress: Many children can strum basic chords and play recognizable tunes early on, which builds motivation.
- Versatility: From pop to rock to folk, guitar spans genres that kids often recognize and enjoy.
- Cool factor: For many kids, holding a guitar feels empowering, like being in a band, even before they know a single chord.
Keep in mind:
- Small-scale guitars exist, but younger kids (under 7) may still struggle with arm reach or finger strength.
- Coordination between strumming and fretting hands can be tricky at first, especially for smaller children.
Violin: A Classical Entry Point with Scaled Sizes
Violin offers an entirely different musical experience, especially for kids who are drawn to orchestras, classical music, or the idea of playing in a string ensemble.
Why the violin works for young learners:
- Scaled sizing: Violins come in fractional sizes (1/8, 1/4, 1/2, etc.), making it one of the most size-adjustable instruments for children as young as 4 or 5.
- Pitch awareness: Since violins don’t have frets, students develop a strong ear and sense of intonation early on.
- Foundational discipline: The violin’s steeper learning curve fosters patience, focus, and long-term persistence.
Things to consider:
- Producing a clear sound takes practice, squeaks early-on are common.
- Bow control and posture are essential from the start, which can feel challenging to young beginners.
Three Things That Matter More Than the Instrument
1. Your Child’s Interest
This is the most important factor. If your child lights up at the sound of a violin or can’t stop mimicking guitar riffs, follow their lead. A motivated student learns faster and sticks with it longer.
Try this:
- Watch a few performance videos together (solo violin, acoustic guitar, orchestra, etc.)
- Attend a local concert or recital
- Book a trial lesson for each instrument and see what clicks
2. Physical Fit
Violin and guitar both require different body mechanics. Guitar requires some finger strength and stretch, while violin posture depends heavily on chin, shoulder, and arm positioning.
Our teacher-match process at Forbes Music ensures that students are paired with instructors who can assess physical readiness and recommend appropriately sized instruments.
3. Your Goals for Lessons
Are you hoping to nurture long-term musicianship? Build confidence? Support school band or orchestra goals? Let those answers help guide your choice.
What Our Teachers Say
Many of our experienced instructors agree: There’s no wrong choice, just the right match for your child’s personality, curiosity, and developmental stage.
- Guitar may suit kids who want early success, recognizable songs, and flexibility in genre
- Violin is great for children who are patient, precise, and drawn to orchestral or classical music
In either case, our teachers adapt lessons to fit your child’s learning style, pace, and musical preferences.
Still Not Sure? We Can Help
Choosing between violin and guitar isn’t about picking the “better” instrument, it’s about starting with one that aligns with your child’s interests, age, and natural strengths.
At Forbes Music, we specialize in helping families start smart. Whether your child strums, bows, or switches later on, we’ll help you find the right teacher that will make the first steps count.
